My sec1 kid has a basic model for text and call. The P4 kid calls from the school pay phone before leaving the premises

If they need to travel alone it’s best to give a phone for tracking and contacting them

Yes but take it from them at nights till they come to a correct age

I think yes for safety and also easy communication

They need to if they are going out on their own.

It's a huge distraction! I've learnt my lesson!

Depends on their maturity and responsibility.

We don't believe in giving mobile phones.

My kids are addicted to their phones :(

Depends on age. Upper Primary yes.